International Monetary Fund (IMF) believes that countries, which don't
initiate pension & healthcare reforms, might be forced to hike taxes
to finance social welfare of aging populations.
In
a staff discussion note (SDN) titled 'The Fiscal Consequences of
Shrinking Populations' issued by IMF notes that population growth that
implies the population doubling every 35 years or so is unsustainable.
Nevertheless, shrinking populations pose a grave fiscal threat.
SDN
elaborates: "Absent further reforms, age-related spending is expected
to rise because of higher longevity and lower fertility in both more and
less developed countries. Without the implementation of further reforms
of public pension and health care systems, age-related outlays are
expected to increase over 2015–2100 from 16½ to 25 percent of GDP in the
more developed economies, and from 5½ to 16 percent of GDP in the less
developed economies."
It
continues: "The fiscal consequences of this outcome are dire: spending
increases of such a magnitude could lead to unsustainable increases in
public debt and, sharp declines in other spending, or it could
necessitate large increases in tax rates that could stymie economic
growth."
It
adds: "declining populations can reduce economic growth and - if not
accompanied by a commensurate reduction in interest rates—make it more
difficult for countries to reduce their public debt as a share of GDP."
Pointing
out that there is no escape from reforming entitlements, SDN says: "In
the more developed economies, one priority remains to limit the
excessive growth of health care costs."
It
points out that further reforms would also be needed to contain the
growth in pension spending, which seems relatively mild reflecting past
reforms. Increasing retirement ages in line with longevity gains seems a
promising option. In the less developed economies, the challenge is to
strengthen public pension and health care schemes, while ensuring the
expenditure increases are fiscally sustainable. Tax and spending
policies encouraging higher labor participation rates for women and for
young and old workers will also be necessary in both more and less
developed countries.
SDN
has concluded that a gradual pace of reform to pension and health
systems would help to spread the burden across generations. There is
greater urgency to move on health care as countries have been slow in
implementing reforms in this area. In this regard, policy reversals
should be avoided to circumvent disruptive adjustments in the future. In
many countries, a multipronged approach will be needed, as it will be
impossible for reforms to fully offset the impact of demographics on
age-related spending.
In
this context, many countries will need to strengthen their tax systems
and improve the efficiency of public spending programs outside of
pensions and health.
|